2000 for 2014: Sales estimates for the Top Thousand Comics and Graphic Novels

With today’s release of December comics orders from Diamond Comic Distributors — and our subsequent analysis and estimates for December 2014 comics sales now posted — Comichron has drawn upon that information to project estimates for the Top Thousand Comics and the Top Thousand Graphic Novels for 2014. Click to see them.

http://www.mycomicshop.com/search?q=amazing+spider-man+1&pubid=&PubRng=&AffID=874007P01The tables are on the page just beneath the image links to individual months. As
in past years, it is a large page, necessarily, so it may take a bit to
load. Also as in the past, I have rounded off estimates to the nearest hundred comics.

Before launching into a discussion of what’s on the list, some more general thoughts on 2014, now that we’ve seen all the data:

• Last winter stank, but it didn’t matter. Headlines for comics sales in January, February, and March 2014 were dire in many places (though not here); the Direct Market was off 4% in the first quarter, overall, or about $5 million. But comics shops made that up in April alone. Across the next three quarters. the market was up 7.1%, or $28 million — allowing the final comics and graphic novel total sale for the year to be up more than 4%, or $23 million to $540.4 million.

It’s a good reminder that not all sales seasons are created equal (especially not as January 2014 had one of its weeks given to December 2013 in the accounting), and that the amount of volume in the market is what matters. It is also a good reminder as we look ahead to the figures for the first part of this year, which will be infused by Star Wars #1‘s blockbuster sales: its effect is likely to be even further amplified given the lower amount of releases to the market in the winter. The addition of a million-copy book to a market that might only see 6 or 7 million copies sold in January could be quite significant.

• 2014 was not the year of the blockbuster — despite a new top-selling comic book for the century. As noted further below, Amazing Spider-Man #1 from April broke all sales records from the last fifteen years — but it was largely an outlier, as six months out of twelve the top-seller for the month was the book that leads the list when no blockbusters are around: Batman. (Not that Batman’s sales haven’t been blockbuster some months in the past, just that it is the typical industry leader in non-event months.) This seems to have played out in the charts in general, as we see in the Top Thousand and the larger indexes that the upper tier books didn’t carry as much weight this year, even as comics sales overall grew.

Here’s some visible evidence of the shape of the market, as seen on the lists. We find the following breakdowns for unit sales:


200,000+ 100,000+ 75,000+ 50,000+ 25,000+ 10,000+
2009 2 39 119 379 n.a. n.a.
2010 0 26 94 303 955 n.a.
2011 3 42 86 343 984 n.a.
2012 5 63 129 403 1100 2250
2013 6 64 178 390 1128 2430
2014 4 40 108 401 1195 2353
way to look at the above is: where does the 100,000-copy level start on
the chart? In 2010, every book above 26th place sold that many copies
or more; in 2014, six-figures started at 40th place.


you can see, the upper tiers, above 75,000 copies, fell off
dramatically from 2013 to 2014. But the next tiers bulked up. The best
guess is that about 3,800 comics sold at least 5,000 copies — which
makes sense, considering that’s about where the 300th place cutoff is
each month these days.

Now to that list. The Top Thousand Comics
account for around 52.07 million copies; that’s well over half of all
the comics that Diamond sold. The figure is down from 54.21 million
copies in 2013, though Diamond’s unit sales of comics overall were up
0.25%.  In 2012 the figure was 53.43 million copies; in 2011, it was 47
copies, and in 2010, the
total was 45.3 million copies.

Using our database to
project sales for other issues, it appears that the Top 2,500 Comics for
the year sold around 78 million copies, down from 79 million in 2013.
So the farther down the list we go, the more the unit sales picture

In full retail
dollars, the Top Thousand Comics sold for $201.03 million, a $1
million drop from last year’s total of $202.02 million. (See the 2013 article here and charts here.)
Again, since Diamond’s dollar sales for comics were up 4%, it’s clear
that the highest-selling comics were not where the growth was last year —
but rather, the titles selling fewer than 25,000 copies each. And it’s
growth from 2012’s figure, which was $191.4 million. (See the 2012
article here and charts here.)

Doing the same estimating for the Top 2,500 Comics puts 2014 ahead of 2013, $294 million versus $288 million.

Once again this year, almost every single one of the Top 100 comics on the list had a
“multiple order codes” notation from Diamond, meaning there were
variant covers or reprints combined to make the main entry.

Top Thousand Graphic Novels, led by Saga Vol. 3,
went for $81.19 million, up from $79.03 million in 2013, from $71.4
million in 2012, and from $58.4 million in 2011. Combined, the Top
Thousand Comics and Top Thousand Graphic Novel lists account for about
52% of the orders by dollars Diamond received in

publishing last year, which was around $540 million. That percentage is
down from 54% in 2013 and 55% in 2012. Again, the best-selling books are
accounting for less and less, even as the pie grows larger.


http://www.mycomicshop.com/search?q=amazing+spider-man+583&pubid=&PubRng=&AffID=874007P01The renumbered Amazing Spider-Man #1 was the top seller of the year; Comichron estimates that, all told,
around 559,200 copies of the issue, including all variants, were ordered
by Direct Market retailers in North America. That’s enough to make it the highest-selling comic book of the 21st Century
through the end of 2014; Marvel’s Star Wars #1, released last week,
will easily surpass it, but we won’t see it on the list until Diamond
releases its 2015 end-of-year data next year.

So it
will be a short reign for the Spider-Man issue atop the list — less than
a year. The issue takes the spot held for five years by the Obama Amazing Spider-Man #583, with orders of 530,500 copies in 2009. You can see the updated top-sellers by year here.

The entire Top Comics of the 21st Century list has been updated, and it has been split into lists for the decade of 2000-2009 and the decade of the 2010s. One more comic book from 2014, Walking Dead #132,
cracked the Top 10 for the Century, landing at #8. It’s the third year
in a row an issue from the series has broken into the list, but this one
comes with a dagger in our charts, noting that most of its sales came
from a single gigantic purchase by the repackager Loot Crate. While the
copies were sold by Diamond and can’t be separated out, it is worth some
kind of footnote so readers in future years will know why this one
issue ranked the way it did.

The Top 10 since 2000, up to 2014:

Issue Ship Price Publisher Est. sales
1 Amazing Spider-Man (new series) 1 Apr-14 $5.99 Marvel 559,200
2 Amazing Spider-Man 583 Jan-09 $3.99 Marvel 530,500
3 Walking Dead (including Chromium edition) 100 Jul-12 $3.99 Image 384,800
4 Civil War 2 Jun-06 $2.99 Marvel 341,900
5 Civil War 3 Jul-06 $2.99 Marvel 337,000
6 Walking Dead 115 Oct-13 $2.99 Image 329,300
7 Civil War 1 Feb-13 $3.99 Marvel 328,500
8 Walking Dead† 132 Oct-14 $2.99 Image 326,300
9 Justice League of America 1 Feb-13 $3.99 DC 326,000
10 Captain America 25 Mar-07 $3.99 Marvel 317,700

Uncanny Avengers #1 and Civil War #4 were bumped from the Top 10.

Fourteen issues from 2014 made the Top 300
for the 21st Century list, once again fewer than last year. Five 2014 issues made the Top 100, and four made the Top 50.

Who published the Top Thousand Comics this year? Here’s the breakdown:

Marvel: 512 (+20 from 2013)
DC: 407 (-3 from 2013)
Image: 57 (+8 from 2013)
Dark Horse: 14 (-4 from 2013)

Archie: 4
(+3 from 2013)
Titan: 3 (+3 from 2013)
IDW: 1
(-14 from 2013)
Valiant: 1 (unchanged from 2013)
Dynamite: 1 (unchanged from 2013)

That’s a pretty short list, with Aspen and Boom dropping out. Titan made the list, thanks to Doctor Who. Marvel picked up a bunch, while the biggest drop-off belonged to IDW, mostly for the reason that My Little Pony isn’t as high on the charts as it was in 2013.

And here’s the publisher breakdown of the Top Thousand Graphic Novels. Those with 10 or more entries:

DC: 393 (+31 from 2013)
Marvel: 251 (-37 from 2013)

Image: 115 (+19 from 2013)
Dark Horse: 88 (-3 from 2013) 

IDW: 36 (-6 from 2013)
Random House: 25 (+8 from 2013)
Boom: 19 (+7 from 2013)

Viz: 17 (+1 from 2013)
Oni: 10 (+1 from 2013)

Marvel’s loss is almost the size of DC’s gain, and Image picked up a lot. Random House and Boom also made headway into the list.

Walking Dead
softcovers and hardcovers in the Top 2,500 added up to more than $6.5
million at retail — with comics bringing the total for the line up to
nearly $10.8 million. That’s enough to give it a market share of exactly
2%, which would make it once again the seventh largest publisher for
the year, after Dynamite were it a separate firm.


The average cost of the comic books retailers ordered in the Top Thousand was $3.86, but that goes down to $3.79 when you extend the chart to the Top 2,500. The average comic book offered in 2014 only cost $3.72, so people are tending toward the more expensive comics. This may also explain why the books at the top of the charts aren’t pulling the same weight as they had before when it comes to number of units moved: the books atop the charts were more likely to cost more.

With the December data, we now have a 20-year monthly track on comics sales. While average prices on the covers of all offerings (the black line) and the average price of all the comics retailers bought (the red line) have been increasing, we note that they haven’t been too far off what prices would have been if they followed inflation exactly. The green line below tracks what the average comic book at the end of 2014 — $2.25 — would have cost if it followed the inflation rate exactly:

Since comics are linked to prices to other goods and services — like paper and ink, and what it costs to hire talent — it’s not too surprising that the average prices tend to have been a bit higher. And we can see that there have been times in which prices have increased faster than others: particularly 2008-2010, when major publishers tried to go from $2.99 to $3.99 in defiance of the general recession the rest of the economy was suffering. Comics publishers pulled back on price increases at that point. But generally, we might expect that a $2.25 comic book in 1994 ought to cost about $3.50 now — which it might if most publishers didn’t eschew half-dollar increments. We’re not far off of that.

To a degree, some of the perception of high comics prices comes from a lack of collective memory about what comics used to cost: look back on monthly changes over time and annual median prices since 1961 here. And the track of the green line above would be different depending on what year it started in: 1994 was a year in which paper supply was in great demand, and so that $2.25 baseline could already have been high. But there generally haven’t been many wild departures from inflation in the general economy in the last 20 years.

Repeating the end-of-year report,
the comic shop market in North America ordered more than $540 million
worth of comics and graphic novels in 2014, an increase of 4% over 2013.
The final end-of-year report, bringing in outside channels and digital, will appear
later this year, but the comics portion of the figure is likely close to $357 million, with $178 million coming from graphic novels and the balance coming from magazines. You can look back on the 2013 Overall charts here.

There are 23 other years of Diamond annual reports on the site, going back to 1991. You can also find comparatives for how the market as a whole did across that time by viewing our Yearly Comics Sales page.

Support research by Comichron on Patreon!